Product-Review-Crew
Best Overall Drugstore Mascara

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

An exceptional drugstore mascara that delivers impressive length and volume with a flexible wand, a wide shade range, and easy removal.

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara – buy now
4.7(1,122 reviews)
$13 - $16

via Amazon.com

Check Price at Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Pros
  • +Delivers exceptional length and volume with tiny bamboo fibers at a budget-friendly price
  • +Ultra-flexible, tapered wand provides precise, mess-free application from corner to corner
  • +Available in one of the widest shade ranges, including black, brown, burgundy, blue, green, and plum
Cons
  • Formula is slick and wet, which may require a few seconds to dry between coats
  • Some users with very oily eyelids may experience minor smudging by the end of a long day
  • The flexible brush can feel less sturdy compared to traditional fiber wands
See how this compares to similar productsFull Comparison →

The Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara has become a viral sensation for good reason, consistently ranking as a top performer across numerous beauty editor reviews. This mascara utilizes tiny bamboo fibers to create a remarkable lengthening and volumizing effect, making even the shortest lashes look dramatically longer and fuller. The ultra-flexible, tapered wand is a standout feature, allowing for precise and even application that reaches every lash from the inner corner to the outer edge without clumping or mess. One of its greatest strengths is its incredible shade range, which extends beyond classic black to include brown, burgundy, blue, green, and plum, allowing users to customize their look. The formula is slick and wet, ensuring it coats each lash evenly, but it does require a moment to dry between layers. While it holds up well against flaking and smudging for most users, those with very oily eyelids might notice some transfer after extended wear. The flexible wand, while precise, may feel less robust than traditional bristle brushes. However, its easy removal with just warm water and a gentle touch makes it a convenient and reliable choice. For its combination of high performance, versatility, and accessible price point, it stands as the best overall drugstore mascara available.

Last updated:

Sarah MitchellHealth & Fitness Editor

Sarah covers health, fitness, and personal care products. With a background in sports science, she brings evidence-based analysis to every recommendation.

Product FAQs

Yes, for most buyers. The Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara stands out for: Delivers exceptional length and volume with tiny bamboo fibers at a budget-friendly price and Ultra-flexible, tapered wand provides precise, mess-free application from corner to corner. The main trade-offs are Formula is slick and wet, which may require a few seconds to dry between coats. Check our full Beauty and Personal Care comparison for alternatives.