Garmin Index S2 - Best Smart Scale for Garmin Ecosystem Users
The Garmin Index S2 excels for Garmin device owners with perfect ecosystem integration and reliable body composition tracking.
- +Seamless integration with Garmin Connect
- +Color display shows multiple metrics
- +Accurate measurements in testing
- -High price point for limited features
- -App lacks detailed metric explanations
- -Requires frequent calibration
The Garmin Index S2 delivers optimal performance for users already invested in the Garmin ecosystem, automatically syncing data with Garmin Connect to provide a comprehensive health overview alongside activity tracking. Its color display cycles through weight, BMI, and body composition metrics without requiring app access, a convenience feature not found on many competitors. Testing showed the scale provides accurate measurements that matched professional equipment within acceptable margins. However, the premium price seems unjustified given the limited additional functionality compared to more affordable alternatives.
The companion app focuses primarily on data display rather than offering the educational content or analysis found in competing apps. Users report needing to recalibrate the scale frequently when moving it, which may frustrate those who store their scale between uses. For dedicated Garmin users, the seamless integration with existing devices and services may outweigh these limitations, but the Index S2 offers less value for those outside the Garmin ecosystem. Its automatic user recognition works well for households with distinct weight ranges but may require manual profile selection for similar-weight individuals.